MeWe.com has been described as an alternative to Facebook. I have gathered here comments on it and want to propose it as an exemplar of a social network. Sir Tim Berners Lee sits on the MeWe board, so a trusted authority helps to guide its design.
(Note: moved here from Example of Humane Social Network: Openbook)
Haven’t heard of it but has anyone had any experience with MEWE? They took out a full page ad in the NYTimes recently.
Examplar of Humane Tech Social Network: Openbook
I’ve been on MeWe for several weeks now and am very happy with it. I don’t have the social circle I had before, but that’s OK. A few close friends followed me, so when we respond to each other, it feels more immediate and intimate.
I have also created a MeWe page for my office https://mewe.com/join/manoa_journal and promoted it on our Facebook page. People are coming over, one at a time. On our MeWe page, I post content not available on FB or our website.
MeWe also has features FB doesn’t and is FREE OF ADS! I can’t stress enough what a difference that makes.
The other big plus is that when a friend posts something on MeWe, it gets a lot of my attention. My attention is not divided among ads, other people’s posts, recommendations of friends, and so forth. MeWe makes possible that focused, more concentrated attention.
Yes, I can! Mewe is a social network which has been around for a while. It is different from many in that it does not do bad things with user data. It has a privacy bill of rights. I have supported the concept because a social network which respects privacy is a good thing. Yes Mark and I chat every now and again. Disclaimer: I have some shares. I use it to a certain extent as well. I have (not surprisingly) suggested that they should give every user automatically some solid space - a solid pod. I don’t know whether their engineering team will be able to pull it off before anyone else! But to go back to their core mission, to respect user’s privacy, they deserve respect for that – whether or not they are solid compatible. People who have found the abuse of privacy elsewhere frustrating have ended up there.
Interesting discussion ensues. Google is shutting down their Google+ social network 3 months early because of a data breach, and a huge mass of users are now looking to find a new social media home. MeWe is trying to get a good share of that pie.
There is also mention of OpenBook looking to incorporate Solid into their social network (though they will continue to be a centralized for the time being).
Examplar of Humane Tech Social Network: Openbook
Digi Rights: Applying fundamental Human Rights to the Digital Realm
I’ve just sent a request to join the Human Tech group in MeWe. I want to go deeper on this social network. I’ve used my name for the request: Germán
A new piece on MeWe:
How to validate the Privacy-First claims of MeWe?
One purpose of having the Exemplars of Humane Technology category is to monitor in which ways the exemplar adheres to humane tech, and discuss where things can be improved.
In this regard Nick Bell posted this to the Solid forum:
“MeWe has not earned trust yet - it’s easy to say you’re pro-privacy but confirmation requires endorsement either with time or critical analysis of source code.”
A good point. And some follow-ups:
"What exactly does MeWe need to do to satisfy your concern that it is pro-privacy? Should it submit to an independent audit? Should it publish its source code? Should open data models be the one ones acceptable for online businesses that promise to protect one’s data?" by Frank Bajak
“It is hard for any company to take a convincing position on privacy, or anything else. How can they be held to account? We’ve seen time and again how over time users offered one thing end up being caught with another. It’s a tricky problem for companies and users. Companies can gain trust in various ways, but it is right that we should not rely on words alone.” by Mark (the Webalyst)
Not giving any opinion, but it is worth investigating the privacy-first claims in more detail.
How to validate the business model and mission of MeWe?
In the same Solid forum thread as mentioned in previous post, there was a post to a Google Plus discussion regarding Google+ users (Google’s social network that will be shutdown soon) mass-migrating to MeWe.
The question raised is whether MeWe can be recommended as a migration target, given that it is created by a private, for-profit, venture-capital (VC) funded business. Is MeWe any different than, say, a young early-days Facebook, making promises to improve the world?
Because Google+ will shutdown, I copied the discussion thread to its own topic (it is quite long to add here): Google+ users on whether they can recommend MeWe as a social network to migrate to.
Again taking no opinion (I am not a MeWe user myself), this point is worthy of more discussion.